The pnpm generai impact evaluation project was carried out in three waves. Your evaluation team has been entrusted with the responsibility of evaluating the generasi programs impact on health and education outcomes. World bank, the decentralization support facility, the netherlands embassy, and the pnpm support facility, which consists of donors from australia, the united kingdom, the netherlands, and denmark, and the spanish impact evaluation fund, and funding for the analysis came in part from nih under grant p01 hd0615. Pnpmrural and its health and education pilot program, pnpmgenerasi have led to school facility improvements and reduced school costs for poor families. Evaluation use for policy, program, and project planning. Longterm generasi impact evaluation report is a product of social, urban. The second wave was conducted from october 2008 to january 2009, after 15 to 18 months of generasi implementation. Acknowledgments v glossary vi executive summary 7 1. It invovl es identifying strategic elements inputs, outputs. Furthermore, a comparison of the effectiveness of household and community cash transfers is important for policy options to overcome the aforementioned limitations of household ccts. Intenttotreat parameters were estimated using linear regression and logistic regression. This document describes the findings from the interim evaluation survey conducted between october and december 2007, after 15 to 18 months of generasi implementation in. Objective to analyse the effectiveness of a household conditional cash transfer programme cct on antenatal care anc coverage reported by women and anc quality reported by midwives.
Pnpm support facility psf request to the jmc for an additional allocation to an existing project. Budiyatiqualitative impact study for pnpmgenerasi and pkh on the provision and the utilization of the maternal and child health services and basic. The international initiative for impact evaluation 3ie is an international. Qualitative impact study for pnpm generasi and pkh on the provision and the utilization of the maternal and child health services and basic education services in the provinces of west java and east. The project design was based on the results of a 2011 rigorous impact evaluation, which. The development objective of pnpm generasi is to empower local. Pnpm national community empowerment program healthy and smart generation. Financial support for the overall pnpm generasi program and the evaluation surveys has come from the. Impact evaluation design september 12, 2014 updated april 17, 2019.
Manual for generasi technical operations pto 2016 has been revised and nol has been. The ifad impact evaluation guidelines accordingly define impact as the the attainment of development goals of the project or program, or rather the contributions. Generasi national program for community empowerment smart and healthy generation in. The impact of household and community cash transfers on. Lessons from the compact millennium challenge corporation. Primary school enrollment is close to universal for both boys and girls, and the child mortality rate has declined rapidly. Evaluating the impact of conditional cash transfer programs, world bank research observer, world bank group, vol. The nutrition project sought to improve a range of maternal and child health outcomes, particularly stunting, with the ultimate goal of reducing poverty. However, this impact study is delayed, so that data cannot be obtained yet.
Communities, with assistance from pnpm facilitators, work with health and education. Sep 26, 20 the pnpm generasi impact evaluation project was carried out in three waves. The evaluation, currently in progress, measures primarily. In generasi, block grants were allocated to village management team who gets to decide on which activities to be funded toward health and education. Assessing the political impacts of a conditional cash transfer evidence from a randomized policy experiment julia e. The impact of household and community cash transfers on childrens food consumption in indonesia. The evaluation of the nutrition project addresses three key research questions, which focus on both impacts and implementation.
The third and final evaluation survey was implemented from october 2009 to january 2010 after 27 to 30 months of project implementation. Indonesia longterm impact evaluation of generasi indonesia has made remarkable strides in key human development indicators over the past few decades. Pnpm generasi program and the evaluation surveys has come from the government of indonesia, the world bank, the decentralization support facility, the netherlands embassy, and the pnpm support. Participation in the cct programs has been randomized over subdistricts to directly measure impact, following the example of cct programs elsewhere in the world most notably in latin america. The pnpm generasi impact evaluation project was carried out in three waves. Pnpm support facility psf request to the jmc for an. Since 2008, adb has supported the ris pnpm project of the ministry of public works. Assessing the political impacts of a conditional cash. It invovl es identifying strategic elements inputs. Indonesia longterm impact evaluation of generasi english. During the design stage, the independent evaluator proposed a 5 percent effect size as a reasonable effect size to expect based on the project cost.
Indonesia impact evaluation of pnpm generasi program. Acknowledgements longterm generasi impact evaluation report is a product of social, urban, rural and resilience global practices team in the world ank office jakarta. Pnpm generasi in the first year of the program villages. Assessing the political impacts of a conditional cash transfer. Identifying impacts on education and health in the presence of treatment externalities, econometrica, econometric society, vol.
Pnpm generasi has had three waves of evaluation, including a baseline survey 2007 and midterm impact evaluation 2009, and final. Wwwmccovidoesiastarreport 5 mieim caee corporatio dedicated procurement service units psus in a diverse set of government entities. Indonesia communitybased health and nutrition overview. Policy and institutional reforms millennium challenge. The revised analysis incorporates the updated program design as well as additional data from the impact evaluation of the pnpm generasi which facilitated. The baseline survey took place from june 2007 to august 2007. On average, pnpm generasi had a statistically significant positive impact on the twelve target health and education indicators, with the greatest impacts observed in areas with low baseline health and education indicators. Pnpm generasi has had three waves of evaluation, including a baseline survey 2007 and midterm impact evaluation 2009, and final impact evaluation 2011. Pnpmgenerasi national community empowerment program. Final impact evaluation report june 2011 benjamin a.
An integral part of the program is the evaluation desig n. Through the existing pnpm rural platform and utilizing the communitydriven development cdd approach, pnpm generasi uses community planning and incentivized subdistrict grants to improve outcomes in terms of 12 priority health and education indicators. Indonesia has made remarkable strides in key human development indicators over the past few decades. Communitybased health and nutrition to reduce stunting project. Results for main indicators, java split by percapita consumption quintile, model 2 99 table 31. The project design was based on the results of a 2011 rigorous impact evaluation, which found that an existing national project in indonesia was delivering positive health and school enrollment impacts at the community level. Indonesias pnpm generasi program final impact evaluation report. Indonesia longterm impact evaluation of generasi english abstract.
What have been the impacts of world bank communitydriven. Mcc indonesia nutrition project impact evaluation design. Indonesia impact evaluation of pnpm generasi program 2007. The objective of the project is that villagers in pnpm rural locations benefit from improved socioeconomic and local governance conditions.
Through a community driven development process, empowered citizens develop their own solutions to. Demandside financing, where funds for specific services are channelled through, or to, prospective users, is now employed in health and education sectors in many low and middleincome countries. Pnpm is listed in the worlds largest and most authoritative dictionary database of abbreviations and acronyms. Local solutions to poverty lsp is a multidonor trust fund thats assisting the government to improve the quality of life of poor and vulnerable indonesians. Timeframe depends on depth and breadth of evaluation, design and. We begin by examining the impact of the incentives on the 12 main indicators. Department of economics junko onishi, the world bank susan wong, the world bank. The evaluation also showed that the program successfully targeted program benefits. Impact evaluation of pnpm generasi program 2007, first wave, baseline survey. The effects of a household conditional cash transfer.
Indonesia impact evaluation of pnpm generasi program 2009. Where it is assessed that the merits of activity indicate an activity should proceed, even though a negative impact may result, this framework outlines the standard operating procedures that have been incorporated in pnpm rural iii to minimize and offset those negative impacts. Increase the impact and effectiveness of the program for job creation. This document describes the findings from the interim evaluation survey conducted between october and december 2007, after 15 to 18 months of generasi implementation in 129 treatment sub districts. Minimum attendance rate of 85% for all primary school aged children value quantitative or qualitative 96. Design the cct was piloted as a cluster randomised control trial in 2007. The main findings of the pnpm generasi final impact evaluation are as follows. Pnpm generasi national community empowerment program. Pnpm generasi positively impacted all targeted health and education indicators. Pnpm rural and its health and education pilot program, pnpm generasi have led to school facility improvements and reduced school costs for poor families. Effects of demandside financing on utilisation, experiences. Quantitative methods and practices, world bank, 2010.
Indonesia longterm generasi qualitative study in 2007, the government of indonesia goi introduced pnpm generasi national community empowerment programhealthy and smart generation, program nasional pemberdayaan masyarakatgenerasi sehat dan cerdas to address key policy priorities and the millennium. Through a community driven development process, empowered citizens develop their own solutions to reduce poverty and inequality. Indonesias pnpm generasi program final impact evaluation. This document describes the findings from the threewave evaluation series carried out from 2007 to 2010.
273 939 684 864 1239 1301 368 387 352 1529 806 772 757 1197 1443 1265 1402 1145 835 86 1585 426 693 1542 1070 545 430 1531 209 61 1439 553 1492 74 1240 815 1337 1462 1020 658 1029 1408 1150 1358 527 599